July 20, 2018 BY Vision Zero Networkin News

On the Way to Vision Zero: San Francisco’s Crisis Response Team, a Model Program

Tragically, we are still far from reaching Vision Zero in most of our communities, as people’s lives are shattered or even lost each day simply while walking, biking, or driving. These preventable deaths and injuries are, of course, tragic enough. Yet, victims’ loved ones may have their grief compounded even further with feelings of frustration at missed opportunities for support at a cripplingly difficult time.

San Francisco City and County staff decided that was unacceptable and vowed to improve the situation. After hearing the experiences of members of the San Francisco Bay Area (SFBA) Families for Safe Streets, a year ago, they developed a Crisis Response Team to better support families who have lost a loved one in a traffic crash.

“We attended one of their meetings to understand the perspective of these families,” said Megan Wier, Director of the Program on Health, Equity & Sustainability at the San Francisco Public Health Department and co-chair of San Francisco’s Vision Zero task force. “It was sobering and sad. It was moving and very brave of the families to share with us.”

Confusion Amid Grief

Historically, about 30 people die annually on San Francisco streets. San Francisco has committed to the goal of zero traffic deaths and severe injuries, and the Crisis Response Team is a way of acknowledging that San Francisco is not there yet and wants to do more for those who suffer.

Members of SFBA Families for Safe Streets, one of seven chapters of an organization first founded in New York City, said that it was difficult to navigate the steps from death notification through confirmation and that communication gaps between and within city agencies meant they didn’t know about available support services. Some families said they heard about the death in the media before they even knew it was their child. They also said that when they went to the police department to confirm the victim’s identity, they felt criminalized.

Previously, the San Francisco’s District Attorney’s office was only involved when it was a criminal case, said Deputy Chief Jackie Ortiz, Victim Services Division of the DA’s Office.

“After hearing the family members talk about it, it bothered me,” said Ortiz, a veteran of the office for more than 30 years. “Even if we can’t offer them victim compensation, we should navigate them through the system.”

Creating a More Coordinated, Compassionate Response

Although the city departments were already offering many services to loved ones of fatal traffic crashes, such as counseling and financial assistance, Wier said, they were not coordinated nor well communicated. Once they received the concerning feedback and as part of their Vision Zero efforts, the various departments began meeting to find solutions. “What is heartening is that everyone immediately understood the need, began to work together, and developed trust,” Wier said.

Timely, coordinated service is now delivered. A protocol checklist was created as well as resource materials in multiple languages. Four departments and the SFBA Families for Safe Streets collaborate: The Medical Examiner’s Office shares the complete medical record with all involved. The Police Department Traffic Collision Investigation Unit, first on the scene, carries small business card-sized explanations of what happens next and resources. Survivors and victims’ loved ones are connected with Public Health Department Crisis Response staff who provide resources and therapy, and the SFBA Families for Safe Streets offers peer support. The SF District Attorney’s Office provides crisis intervention, resources, and referrals as well as assistance accessing California’s Victim Compensation Program.

The District Attorney’s office has about 25 professional advocates, who are on the frontlines. “As soon as we put the protocol and procedures in place, they immediately took to it,” Ortiz said. “They do incredible work. They are dealing with victims who are in trauma on a day-to-day basis. They have the hardest jobs.”

The coordination among the DA’s office, the coroner’s office, and the police department is strong, Ortiz said. “We’re all collaborating together as a team to figure out what is needed to provide streamlined information to these families.”

Stephanie Felder, Director of Comprehensive Crisis Services with the SF Department of Public Health, explains that the existing integrated crisis program that responds to homicides and critical shootings was expanded to include noncriminal traffic fatalities. Her team make sure people receive counseling, assistance with making funeral arrangements, and other support services. “We were used to doing this with trauma,” Felder said. “We’re about helping people.”

The Crisis Response Team continually evaluates how they are doing. Each case is different, and part of their protocol is to check in. “Within a week of a fatality, I schedule a call to keep the communication channels open,” Wier said, “so we can evolve and refine our approach and be as responsive as we can be.”

Integral to Vision Zero Cities

Both Ortiz and Wier encourage other Vision Zero cities to coordinate their crisis response to traffic fatalities, if they don’t already. “This is a need for anyone who is experiencing a traffic fatality,” says Wier. “Any jurisdiction can do better to support people who are often isolated and navigating complex legal and medical issues.”

Many cities have in place a coordinated crisis response for gun violence; traffic violence deserves the same response. Wier adds, “Be responsive to the tragedies that are happening on our streets as we work quickly to eliminate them.”

Have you or someone you love been in a crash? Thanks to the NYC Families for Safe Streets chapter, which offers online services to those who are suffering. Read their guide here.

Related News

Highlights & Inspiration for Winning Funds: Safe Streets & Roads for All
While recent data showing a 4% decrease in traffic fatalities nationally in 2023 over 2022 offers a glimmer of hope, we know that far more attention and resources must be focused on stemming the unacceptable number of preventable roadway deaths and severe injuries in the U.S. The recently announced new round of funding from the […]
Harnessing Public Health Principles for Vision Zero: Near and Long-Term Strategies
With increasing urgency, researchers, advocates and practitioners are asking the question: How do we make our roadway safety efforts in the U.S. more effective and equitable? And increasingly, the most promising responses draw inspiration from the strategies used by the public health profession.  While transportation and public health have long shared a symbiotic relationship, unfortunately,  […]
Equity in Action: Forging Inclusive Vision Zero Safety Strategies
To achieve Vision Zero, we’ve got to recognize and address the disparities in who faces the greatest safety risks on our roadways, sidewalks and bikeways. Today, Black people are killed in crashes at a 30 percent higher rate compared to the white people and those living in low-income communities experience a fatality rate 35 percent […]
Scroll to Top